Editorial · General AI News
Stop Pretending AI Is a Suitable Replacement for Human Thought in Law School
The recent decision by UC Berkeley Law School to ban the use of AI in most student work is a step in the right direction, but it also highlights the tension between the benefits of AI and the need for human thought and critical thinking in legal education. Law schools are struggling to keep up with the rapid advancements in AI technology, and the ease with which students can use AI to complete assignments and exams is undermining the very foundations of legal education. The fact that 57% of US college students use AI in coursework at least weekly, and 95% of UK undergraduates use AI in some form, is a clear indication that something needs to be done.
The use of AI in law school is not just a matter of convenience, but it also has serious implications for the development of critical thinking and analytical skills. When students rely on AI to complete assignments, they are not learning how to think for themselves, and they are not developing the skills they need to succeed in the legal profession. The new policy at UC Berkeley Law School prohibits the use of AI for aid in conceptualizing, outlining, drafting, revising, translating, or editing any work submitted for credit, and it also bans the use of AI during exams. This is a significant step forward, but it is only the beginning.
The numbers are stark. A study found that in courses vulnerable to AI, the share of A grades increased by about 13 percentage points after the debut of ChatGPT. This is not because students are learning more, but because they are using AI to do the work for them. Faculty surveys show that 92% of faculty are concerned about plagiarism or dishonesty facilitated by AI, and it is clear that something needs to be done to address this problem. The use of AI in law school is not just a matter of academic integrity, but it also has serious implications for the future of the legal profession.
The ban on AI use at UC Berkeley Law School is not a ban on the use of technology altogether. Students are still allowed to use AI to tutor themselves or prepare for class, but they are not allowed to use it to complete assignments or exams. This is a sensible approach, as it recognizes the benefits of AI while also ensuring that students are developing the skills they need to succeed in the legal profession. The fact that other law schools are taking notice of this policy and considering similar measures is a positive sign, and it suggests that the legal education community is finally starting to take the problem of AI use seriously.
As we move forward, it is clear that the use of AI in law school is a complex issue that requires a nuanced approach. While AI has the potential to be a powerful tool for legal education, it also has the potential to undermine the development of critical thinking and analytical skills. The ban on AI use at UC Berkeley Law School is a step in the right direction, but it is only the beginning. Law schools need to continue to evolve and adapt to the changing landscape of AI technology, and they need to find ways to ensure that students are developing the skills they need to succeed in the legal profession. This will require a sustained effort and a commitment to putting the needs of students first, but it is essential for the future of legal education.
Editorial perspective - synthesised analysis, not factual reporting.
If you liked this
More editorials.
AI's Role in Unlocking the Secrets of Ancient Scrolls
The world of archaeology and history has long been constrained by the physical limitations of artifacts-fragile scrolls, carbonized parchment, and other relics that crumble at the touch. But a quiet revolution is underway, one where artificial intelligence (AI) is breaking these barriers, allowing us to peek into the past with unprecedented clarity. This editorial explores how AI is transforming our understanding of ancient texts, focusing on its application to the famously enigmatic Herculaneum scrolls. For centuries, scholars have grappled with the charred remains of scrolls buried by Mount Vesuvius in 79 CE. These scrolls, found in a luxury villa near Pompeii, contain invaluable insights into Roman culture, philosophy, and science. Yet, their fragile state has made them nearly impossible to read without risking further damage. Traditional methods of unrolling or imaging these scrolls have yielded limited results-until now. Recent advancements in AI-powered imaging technology are changing the game. By using machine learning algorithms to analyze high-resolution scans of the scrolls, researchers can "virtually unwrap" these ancient texts without touching them. These tools detect subtle patterns in the ink and parchment, revealing letters and words that were previously hidden. In 2023, a breakthrough allowed scientists to read portions of one scroll with remarkable accuracy-marking the first time any Herculaneum text had been fully deciphered since its discovery. This progress is not just about solving ancient puzzles; it's about democratizing access to knowledge. By digitizing and analyzing these texts, AI makes them available to researchers worldwide, fostering collaboration and innovation. Imagine a future where scholars in India or Brazil can contribute equally to the study of Roman history-thanks to technology that bridges gaps of geography and resources. Looking ahead, the implications for historical research are profound. AI could unlock not just the Herculaneum scrolls but other ancient texts, such as cuneiform tablets or Mayan codices. The technology's ability to detect patterns and recognize damaged text will only improve with time. This isn't about replacing human scholars; it's about amplifying their capabilities. However, we must approach this cautiously. Over-reliance on AI risks overshadowing the importance of traditional scholarship. No algorithm can fully capture the nuance of historical context or the interpretive skills that make a scholar an expert. The balance between technology and humanity will be key to maximizing these tools' potential. In conclusion, AI is not just a tool for reading ancient scrolls-it's a gateway to understanding our shared history in ways we've never imagined. By combining human expertise with machine intelligence, we can unlock secrets buried for centuries and rewrite the story of civilization. The future of historical research lies at this intersection of technology and tradition-a future where the past becomes more accessible than ever before.
Stop Pretending AI in Education Is a Simple Solution
The decision by Dartmouth's Tuck School to mandate an AI course for its students is a trend that is gaining momentum in business schools across the country. This move is not just about keeping up with the latest technology, but about acknowledging the complex role AI is playing in education. On one hand, AI tools like ChatGPT are being used by students to improve their efficiency and personalize their learning experience. They are using these tools to summarize articles, generate examples, and explain complex theories in simpler language. However, this convenience comes with a cost, as students are increasingly reliant on AI to do their work for them, rather than learning the material themselves. The use of AI in education also raises important questions about equity and access. Students who have access to premium AI tools have a significant advantage over their peers who do not. This creates a new form of educational inequality, where those who can afford the best tools have a better chance of succeeding. Furthermore, the shift towards AI literacy in education is not just about teaching students how to use AI tools, but also about teaching them how to think critically and use these tools responsibly. This is a complex task that requires a nuanced approach, rather than a simple solution. The move towards AI literacy in education is not just limited to business schools. Many institutions are now focusing on teaching students how to use AI responsibly and effectively. This includes partnering with companies to provide students with hands-on experience with AI tools, as well as offering courses on AI literacy and digital citizenship. For example, some universities are offering graduate certificates in applied AI, while others are providing AI-focused education labs for students. These efforts are aimed at preparing students for a workforce where AI is increasingly prevalent. Despite these efforts, there are still many challenges to be addressed. One of the main concerns is that students are not learning the underlying material, but rather relying on AI to do the work for them. This raises important questions about the value of a degree, and whether students are truly prepared for the workforce. Additionally, the use of AI in education also raises concerns about academic integrity, as students may be using these tools to cheat or plagiarize. To address these challenges, educators need to take a proactive approach to teaching AI literacy, and ensure that students are using these tools responsibly and effectively. The decision by Dartmouth's Tuck School to mandate an AI course is a step in the right direction, but it is only the beginning. As AI continues to play a larger role in education, it is essential that educators take a nuanced approach to teaching AI literacy. This includes addressing the complex issues surrounding equity, access, and academic integrity, as well as ensuring that students are learning the underlying material, rather than just relying on AI to do the work for them. By taking a proactive and responsible approach to AI in education, we can ensure that students are prepared for a workforce where AI is increasingly prevalent, and that they have the skills and knowledge they need to succeed.
The Brain's Language: Unlocking the Secrets Through AI and Neuroscience
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized our understanding of how the human brain processes language. These models can predict brain activity with remarkable accuracy, offering insights into which regions light up in response to specific words or concepts. However, this success comes with a critical challenge: the models themselves are black boxes-vast collections of learned parameters that reveal little about the actual mechanisms at work. While we know that certain brain areas respond to language, we struggle to explain what exactly they are picking up on-whether it’s food, places, numbers, or something else entirely. Generative causal testing (GCT), a groundbreaking framework developed by Microsoft Research and collaborating universities, is tackling this explainability crisis head-on. By distilling the predictions of brain-prediction models into short, readable explanations, GCT bridges the gap between abstract data and concrete understanding. For example, if a model predicts that a specific brain region lights up in response to phrases like “food preparation” or “location names,” GCT verifies this by generating new stories tailored to activate those regions. When subjects hear these stories in a scanner, their brain activity is measured-offering confirmation or refutation of the initial hypothesis. This approach not only validates existing knowledge but also reveals new layers of complexity in how our brains process language. For instance, GCT has teased apart neighboring place-processing regions once thought interchangeable and uncovered tiny prefrontal micro-regions tuned to specific concepts like dialogue, clock times, and measurements. These findings underscore the potential for GCT to transform computational neuroscience by turning black-box models into testable theories rooted in human language and cognition. Looking ahead, the implications of this research are profound. As AI continues to evolve, our ability to understand and explain its inner workings will become increasingly vital. By leveraging GCT, scientists can unlock new insights into the brain’s architecture and function-ultimately paving the way for advancements in education, mental health treatment, and artificial intelligence development. The future of language neuroscience is not just about predicting brain activity; it’s about translating those predictions into meaningful, actionable knowledge that benefits us all.
AI Just Solved a Problem We've Had for Years - Rare Disease Diagnosis Is Finally Getting the Breakthrough It Deserves
For years, families like Jordan Avi Ogman's have faced an excruciating wait for answers. Diagnosed with TECPR2, a fatal neurodegenerative disease, it took nearly four years of confusion and emotional strain to finally identify his condition. This delay is not uncommon-on average, rare disease patients wait five to seven years for an accurate diagnosis. By then, crucial opportunities for treatment may have already slipped away. But now, artificial intelligence is changing the game. Recent advancements in AI tools like OpenAI's o3 Deep Research model and Microsoft's Talos platform are revolutionizing rare disease diagnosis. These systems analyze vast genomic datasets to identify patterns that human researchers might miss. In a study published in NEJM AI, OpenAI's model helped diagnose 18 children at Boston Children's Hospital who had been previously undiagnosed. The AI identified new diagnoses for neurodevelopmental and neuromuscular disorders, among others, achieving a diagnostic yield of nearly 5%. This may seem modest, but consider the context: these cases had already been analyzed multiple times without success. Talos, developed by Microsoft in collaboration with leading research institutions, takes this a step further. By automating reanalysis of genomic data, Talos has delivered over 241 new diagnoses across nearly 5,000 patients. It operates on a simple principle: as our understanding of the genome evolves, so should the analysis of existing genetic data. Unlike traditional methods that rely on manual review, Talos flags only the most likely candidates for human expertise, reducing the workload while maintaining accuracy. The implications are profound. For Jordan and others like him, this means faster access to care and potentially life-saving treatments. By cutting down diagnosis times from years to seconds, AI is not just a tool-it's a lifeline. These breakthroughs highlight the power of combining human expertise with machine learning. While AI does the heavy lifting of sifting through data, doctors can focus on what they do best: interpreting results and providing compassionate care. The future looks promising. As more genetic associations are discovered and AI systems improve, we can expect even greater progress in rare disease diagnosis. Tools like Talos and OpenAI's model demonstrate that automation is not just an efficiency gain-it's a moral imperative. Every delay in diagnosis is a missed opportunity for treatment, and every second saved means hope for families who have waited too long. In the coming years, we can expect AI to play an increasingly vital role in rare disease research. Already, systems like Talos are proving that reanalysis doesn't have to be a one-time effort. By automating this process, we ensure that no genetic data goes unused. This shift represents more than just technological progress-it's a fundamental change in how we approach healthcare challenges. The journey for families like Jordan's is far from over, but the tools emerging from Microsoft and OpenAI offer real hope. Rare disease diagnosis is finally getting the breakthrough it deserves-a future where no one has to wait years for answers.
AI is Transforming the Travel Industry-Here’s How It’s Reshaping Revenue and Customer Experiences
The travel industry is undergoing a quiet revolution powered by artificial intelligence. From optimizing pricing strategies to enhancing customer experiences, AI is reshaping how businesses operate and compete in an increasingly digital world. AI-driven revenue optimization has emerged as a game-changer for travel companies. By leveraging advanced algorithms, these systems analyze vast amounts of data to identify pricing opportunities in real-time, often making adjustments in mere milliseconds. This shift away from static pricing models has already delivered significant results: Mize Data reports that AI-powered solutions have generated over $596 million in incremental profit for hundreds of travel companies globally. This leap in efficiency and profitability underscores the transformative potential of AI in the sector. Beyond revenue optimization, AI is also enhancing customer experiences across every touchpoint. For instance, Expedia Group has integrated AI into its operations to streamline traveler interactions. The company now resolves 80% of contacts within 60 seconds, achieving a 92% first-contact resolution rate across 31 languages in 50 countries. This level of personalization and speed is only possible with AI-driven tools that understand individual preferences and predict customer needs. The future of AI in travel looks promising but also presents challenges. As companies adopt more sophisticated systems, the focus will shift to creating seamless, agnostic platforms that can integrate multiple data sources and channels. The next decade is expected to see the rise of autonomous revenue management systems capable of optimizing across multiple verticals and geographies. In conclusion, AI is not just a tool for tech-savvy companies-it’s becoming a necessity for survival in the travel industry. Businesses that embrace these technologies will gain a competitive edge, delivering superior customer experiences while maximizing profitability. The journey is just beginning, but the impact is already undeniable.